- Refactoring Alzabo's _make_dbh() for Easier DBI Connection Configuration
- The refactoring
- Database Connection Modules, Past and Present
I have factored out the relevant code from Alzabo::Driver::(MySQL|Postgres)::_make_dbh(). I preserved the usage of Params::Validate but replaced the use of Exception::Class with plain Perl die calls. The module is standalone and is called DBIx::DBH.
Composing a syntactically valid DBI DSN is a bit time-consuming and troublesome. Part of the reason for this is that the syntax varies from driver to driver. Another reason is that the DSN string is compound data, representing the complex of a minimum of 3 entities. Since 2001, 3 modules have entered CPAN with the sole and express intent to store DBI database connection information and use this information to provide DBI database handles with ease. However, none of these modules assemble the components of the DSN string into a DSN string --- they all expect completely perfect DSN strings, a non-trivial task.
Recently, I noticed that Alzabo's polymorphic _make_dbh() method could assemble syntactically correct DSN strings from simple-to-supply scalar data items for both Postgres and MySQL. In other words, instead of having to provide a well-formed DSN string like this:
we leave the hard work to _make_dbh by calling it like this
$s->_make_dbh( name => 'mysqldb', host => 'rt.tg.allswell.com', port => 3312, user => 'carlos', pass => 'santana', mysql_local_infile => 1 );
_make_dbh() usage is much easier to read. And much easier to create directly from HTTP form data or configuration files. No doubt everyone has their pet _make_dbh() in the tech stack at their company.
The module DBIx::DBH represents my refactoring of Dave's code. The hash elements have slightly different naming:
the database driver must be supplied
driverkey is used to supply the database
the name key is dbname
the pass key is passed
Another difference is that _make_dbh() called
DBI->connect() with a fixed set of DBI attributes. The refactoring allows for any attributes to be used, both from DBI and from the driver's driver.
The very first module on CPAN for database connection may have been
DBIx::Password by Brian Aker. I sent him patches so he could return a hash of data or array of data for use with supra-DBI tools like Alzabo and DBix::AnyDBD but he refused them. Ima::DBI was also available around this time, but it simply slipped my mind.
So in 2002, I created DBIx::Connect, a Perl module which would use AppConfig configuration files to provide either DBI database handles or a data structure with connection information. This was nice because I could flit from database tool to database tool but only have to catalog my connection information once.
However, DBIx::Connect was based on AppConfig, which was proving itself hard to use - it was not easy to have global data and overwrite it in sub-blocks. I noted these shortcomings here:
and based on suggestions rewrote DBIx::Connect from the bottom up using Sam Tregar's excellent Config::ApacheFormat. Now, I could do anything with config files that you could do with an Apache one. Also, I had much better validation of the config file.
Config::DBI is OK except for two things
- 1 DSN strings are entered as one composite value.
When using an Apache-like configuration file, one thing you find immensely useful is the ability to build up your data in layers, inheriting and over-writing values as necessary.
It is difficult to create such an inheritance hiearchy describing each database when the DSN is specified as a string.
- 2 Config::DBI has rigid expectations of the config file
Software organizations should be entitled to develop configuration files in any manner they desire. Config::DBI expects the file to have a certain structure which may not accord with how the organization wants to describe their database setup
The way around both of these problems was handled by Alzabo's make_dbh() function a long time ago. To handle item 1, you simply run through the hash, looking for keys that can be used in the DSN and assemble them into the DSN string. To handle item 2, you simply expect a hash whose keys are limited to the values in the DBI and driver documentation. How a particular software organization transforms their internal configuration information to this generic hash is their concern.