DBIx::Class::SQLMaker - An SQL::Abstract::Classic-like SQL maker class


This module serves as a mere "nexus class" providing SQL::Abstract::Classic-like functionality to DBIx::Class itself, and to a number of database-engine-specific subclasses. This indirection is explicitly maintained in order to allow swapping out the core of SQL generation within DBIC on per-$schema basis without major architectural changes. It is guaranteed by design and tests that this fast-switching will continue being maintained indefinitely.

Implementation switching

See "connect_call_rebase_sqlmaker" in DBIx::Class::Storage::DBI


Some maintainer musings on the current state of SQL generation within DBIC as of October 2019

Folding of most (or all) of SQL::Abstract::Classic (SQLAC) into DBIC.

The rise of complex prefetch use, and the general streamlining of result parsing within DBIC ended up pushing the actual SQL generation to the forefront of many casual performance profiles. While the idea behind the SQLAC-like API is sound, the actual implementation is terribly inefficient (once again bumping into the ridiculously high overhead of perl function calls).

Given that SQLAC has a very distinct life on its own, and will hopefully continue to be used within an order of magnitude more projects compared to DBIC, it is prudent to not disturb the current call chains within SQLAC itself. Instead in the future an effort will be undertaken to seek a more thorough decoupling of DBIC SQL generation from reliance on SQLAC, possibly to a point where in the future DBIC may no longer depend on SQL::Abstract::Classic at all.

The SQL::Abstract::Classic library itself will continue being maintained although it is not likely to gain many extra features, notably it will NOT add further dialect support, at least not within the preexisting SQL::Abstract::Classic namespace.

Such streamlining work (if undertaken) will take into consideration the following constraints:

Main API compatibility

The object returned by $schema->storage->sqlmaker needs to be able to satisfy most of the basic tests found in the current-at-the-time SQLAC dist. While things like case or logic or even worse convert will definitely remain unsupported, the rest of the tests should pass (within reason).

Ability to replace SQL::Abstract::Classic with a derivative module

During the initial work on Data::Query, which later was slated to occupy the preexisting namespace of SQL::Abstract, the test suite of DBIC turned out to be an invaluable asset to iron out hard-to-reason-about corner cases. In addition the test suite is much more vast and intricate than the tests of SQLAC itself. This state of affairs is way too valuable to sacrifice in order to gain faster SQL generation. Thus the SQLMaker rebase functionality introduced in DBIC v0.082850 along with extra CI configurations will continue to ensure that DBIC can be used with an off-the-CPAN SQLAC and derivatives, and that it continues to flawlessly run its entire test suite. While this will undoubtedly complicate the future implementation of a better performing SQL generator, it will preserve both the usability of the test suite for external projects and will keep SQL::Abstract::Classic from regressions in the future.

Aside from these constraints it is becoming more and more practical to simply stop using SQLAC in day-to-day production deployments of DBIC. The flexibility of the internals is simply not worth the performance cost.

Relationship to SQL::Abstract and what formerly was known as Data::Query (DQ)

When initial work on DQ was taking place, the tools in ::Storage::DBIHacks were only beginning to take shape, and it wasn't clear how important they will become further down the road. In fact the regexing all over the place was considered an ugly stop-gap, and even a couple of highly entertaining talks were given to that effect. As the use-cases of DBIC were progressing, and evidence for the importance of supporting arbitrary SQL was mounting, it became clearer that DBIC itself would not really benefit in any significant way from tigher integration with DQ, but on the contrary is likely to lose crucial functionality while the corners of the brand new DQ/SQLA codebase are sanded off.

The current stance on DBIC/SQLA integration is that it would mainly benefit SQLA by having access to the very extensive "early adopter" test suite, in the same manner as early DBIC benefitted tremendously from usurping the Class::DBI test suite. As far as the DBIC user-base - there are no immediate large-scale upsides to deep SQLA integration, neither in terms of API nor in performance. As such it is unlikely that DBIC will switch back to using SQL::Abstract in its core any time soon, if ever.

Accordingly the DBIC development effort will in the foreseable future ignore the existence of the new-guts SQLA, and will continue optimizing the preexisting SQLAC-based solution, potentially "organically growing" its own compatible implementation. Also, as described higher up, the ability to plug a separate SQLAC-compatible class providing the necessary surface API will remain possible, and will be protected at all costs in order to continue providing SQLA and friends access to the test cases of DBIC.


Check the list of additional DBIC resources.


This module is free software copyright by the DBIx::Class (DBIC) authors. You can redistribute it and/or modify it under the same terms as the DBIx::Class library.